Unfair Dismissal
Comprehensive unfair dismissal services for both employees and employers.
Unfair Dismissal
Whether you're facing dismissal or need to dismiss an employee, we provide expert guidance on unfair dismissal law. Our team ensures proper procedures are followed and helps achieve the best possible outcome.
Key Services
- Dismissal procedures and processes
- Constructive dismissal claims
- Wrongful dismissal advice
- Settlement agreements
- Tribunal representation
- Reinstatement and compensation claims
Related Employment Law Services
Comprehensive employment contract services including drafting, reviewing, and negotiating terms.
Discrimination ClaimsExpert representation in discrimination cases covering all protected characteristics.
RedundancyExpert redundancy advice covering consultation, selection, and compensation.
Workplace HarassmentComprehensive workplace harassment prevention and resolution services for employers and employees.
Disciplinary ProceduresExpert guidance on fair and legally compliant disciplinary procedures for employers and employees.
Whistleblowing ProtectionComprehensive whistleblowing protection services for employees reporting wrongdoing in the workplace.
Why Choose Gardner Champion?
- Experienced employment law specialists
- Practical, business-focused advice
- Strong track record in employment tribunals
- Proactive HR support and training
Need expert legal advice?
Contact us for a personalized consultation and quote for your specific legal needs. All our fees exclude VAT.
Get Free ConsultationDetailed Information
Comprehensive Unfair Dismissal Law and Employee Protection Framework
The Five Potentially Fair Reasons and Range of Reasonable Responses
UK law recognizes five potentially fair reasons for dismissal, but simply having a fair reason is insufficient - employers must also demonstrate they acted reasonably in treating that reason as sufficient for dismissal. Capability dismissals require clear performance standards, appropriate training and support, reasonable improvement timescales, and consideration of alternative roles. Conduct dismissals demand proper investigation, opportunity for the employee to respond, consideration of mitigating factors, and proportionate sanctions. Redundancy dismissals need genuine redundancy situations, fair selection criteria, meaningful consultation, and consideration of alternative employment. The 'range of reasonable responses' test means dismissal must fall within the range of responses a reasonable employer might adopt - not necessarily what the tribunal would have done.
Automatically Unfair Dismissal Categories and Protected Rights
Automatically unfair dismissals protect fundamental employment rights regardless of service length or employer size. Pregnancy-related dismissals include dismissal for pregnancy itself, pregnancy-related illness, taking maternity leave, or exercising maternity rights. Health and safety dismissals protect employees who refuse unsafe work, raise safety concerns, or perform safety representative duties. Whistleblowing protection covers disclosures about criminal offences, legal obligations, miscarriages of justice, health and safety dangers, environmental damage, and cover-ups of such matters. Trade union dismissals protect membership, participation, and recognition activities. The automatically unfair categories continue to expand as Parliament recognizes new areas requiring special protection.
Procedural Requirements and ACAS Code of Practice
Procedural fairness is as important as substantive fairness in dismissal decisions. The ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures sets minimum standards that tribunals expect employers to follow, with potential compensation adjustments for unreasonable failures to comply. Fair procedures require proper investigation of allegations, written notification of issues and meetings, opportunity for employees to respond and be accompanied, consideration of the employee's explanation and mitigating factors, appropriate sanctions given the circumstances, and access to an appeal process. The size and resources of the employer affect procedural expectations, but basic fairness requirements apply to all employers.
Compensation Structures and Remedy Options
Unfair dismissal compensation consists of basic awards (calculated like statutory redundancy pay) and compensatory awards (for actual losses up to statutory caps). Basic awards depend on age, service length, and weekly pay, with current maximums around £17,000. Compensatory awards cover lost wages, benefits, pension rights, and future losses, capped at 52 weeks' pay or around £105,000. Additional awards apply for non-compliance with tribunal orders. Reinstatement and re-engagement remain available but rare remedies. Compensation can be reduced for contributory conduct, failure to mitigate losses, or procedural failures by employees. Understanding compensation structures helps both sides assess case values and settlement prospects.
Constructive Dismissal: Legal Framework and Practical Challenges
Fundamental Breach and the Contract of Employment
Constructive dismissal requires fundamental breach of the employment contract, including express terms (salary, benefits, job description, workplace) or implied terms (trust and confidence, reasonable instructions, safe working environment). The trust and confidence term is particularly important, covering bullying, harassment, discrimination, unreasonable management conduct, failure to investigate grievances, and changes that undermine the employment relationship. The breach must be sufficiently serious to justify immediate resignation - minor breaches or continuing to work normally after the breach can waive the right to claim constructive dismissal. Courts apply objective tests: would a reasonable employee consider the breach sufficiently serious to justify resignation?
The 'Last Straw' Doctrine and Cumulative Breaches
Many constructive dismissal cases involve series of incidents rather than single dramatic breaches. The 'last straw' doctrine allows relatively minor final incidents to trigger resignation if they form part of ongoing fundamental breach patterns. However, the last straw must contribute to the breach pattern - wholly innocuous acts cannot trigger resignation rights even following serious earlier breaches. Timing becomes crucial: employees must resign in response to fundamental breaches without delay, though what constitutes 'delay' depends on circumstances including investigation time, grievance procedures, and practical constraints on resignation.
Grievance Procedures and Alternative Dispute Resolution
Employment tribunals expect employees to raise grievances about constructive dismissal issues before resigning where reasonably practicable. Failure to use internal procedures can reduce compensation by up to 25% under ACAS Code provisions. However, grievance requirements don't apply where procedures are inadequate, the employer is the source of the problem, or using procedures would be futile. Successful grievance resolution can resolve issues without resignation, while unsuccessful grievances strengthen constructive dismissal claims by demonstrating attempts to resolve matters internally. The quality of grievance handling often becomes central evidence in constructive dismissal cases.
Evidence, Documentation, and Proof Challenges
Constructive dismissal claims face particular evidential challenges because employees must prove subjective experiences of workplace treatment while employers control most documentary evidence and witnesses. Successful claims require systematic documentation of incidents, contemporaneous records of conversations and events, witness testimony from colleagues where available, medical evidence of stress or illness impacts, and evidence of attempts to resolve issues internally. Email trails, text messages, and other electronic communications provide crucial evidence. The evidential burden often explains why constructive dismissal claims have lower success rates than ordinary unfair dismissal cases.
Need this handled quickly?
Our experienced solicitors can provide you with a free estimate and priority service.
Request a free estimateFrequently Asked Questions
Help Guides
Facing Dismissal - Your Rights and Options
Essential guide for employees facing dismissal to understand their rights and protect their interests.
Step-by-Step Process
- 1Request details of any allegations or reasons for potential dismissal in writing
- 2Review your employment contract and employee handbook for procedures
- 3Gather evidence supporting your position and any mitigating factors
- 4Prepare for any disciplinary hearings with support from union representative or colleague
- 5Consider raising grievances about the process or treatment you've received
- 6Seek legal advice early to understand your options and potential claims
- 7Keep detailed records of all meetings, decisions, and correspondence
- 8Don't sign any settlement agreements without independent legal advice
Helpful Tips
- Stay professional throughout the process even if you feel unfairly treated
- Ask for adjournments if you need time to prepare or get advice
- Exercise your right to be accompanied to disciplinary hearings
- Consider whether your dismissal might be discriminatory or automatically unfair
Important Warnings
- Don't resign in frustration without considering constructive dismissal claims
- Don't admit to misconduct you haven't committed
- Don't ignore disciplinary invitations as this may be held against you
- Remember you only have three months from dismissal to claim at tribunal
Ready to get started?
Let our expert team handle your legal needs with confidence and care.
Additional Information
Our Process
Our unfair dismissal process begins with urgently assessing your case and gathering evidence. We help with internal procedures where appropriate, negotiate settlements where beneficial, or represent you at employment tribunal. Throughout, we provide clear advice on prospects of success and potential outcomes.
Timeline
Employment tribunal claims must be submitted within three months of dismissal (with early conciliation potentially extending this). Cases typically take 6-12 months to reach hearing, though some settle earlier. We work to resolve matters as quickly as possible while maximizing your compensation.
Costs & Fees
We offer various funding options including no-win-no-fee arrangements, legal expenses insurance, and fixed-fee services. All our legal fees exclude VAT. Many people have legal cover through household insurance or trade union membership. We help you understand all funding options and their implications for your case.
What You'll Need
- Employment contract and any amendments
- Staff handbook and disciplinary policies
- All correspondence about the dismissal process
- Records of disciplinary meetings and outcomes
- Payslips and details of salary and benefits
- Details of any grievances raised
- Evidence supporting your position or mitigating circumstances
- Information about attempts to find alternative employment
Pricing & Service Information
Our Legal Fees
£1,500 - £5,000+ VAT
For employment tribunal representation (unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal claims)
VAT at 20% will be added to all our legal fees
Additional Costs (Disbursements)
These are costs paid to third parties on your behalf:
Employment tribunal fees
No tribunal fees for bringing claims
Expert witness reports
Medical or financial expert reports if required
Counsel fees for hearing
Barrister representation at final hearing (if required)
What's Included
- Initial case assessment and advice on merits
- Preparation of tribunal application or response
- Gathering and reviewing all evidence
- Witness statement preparation
- Correspondence with other party and tribunal
- Case management hearing attendance
- Full tribunal hearing representation
- Settlement negotiations throughout the process
- Regular updates and progress reports
What's Not Included
- Barrister fees (if representation needed at final hearing)
- Expert witness reports beyond basic case requirements
- Costs of obtaining medical or other evidence
- Appeal to Employment Appeal Tribunal
- Enforcement of tribunal awards
Typical Timescales
6-12 months from initial instruction to final hearing
Many cases settle before final hearing. Timeline depends on tribunal availability, case complexity, and whether interim applications are required. Early conciliation through ACAS typically adds 4-6 weeks before tribunal claim can be lodged.
Key Stages of Your Matter
Initial Consultation & Case Assessment
We assess the merits of your case and advise on prospects of success
ACAS Early Conciliation
Mandatory conciliation period before tribunal claim (4-6 weeks)
Tribunal Claim Preparation
Detailed claim form (ET1) drafted with full particulars and evidence
Evidence Gathering & Disclosure
Collecting documents, preparing witness statements, exchanging evidence
Preliminary Hearing (if required)
Case management hearing to set directions and timescales
Settlement Negotiations
Ongoing negotiations to achieve settlement without full hearing
Final Hearing Preparation
Finalizing witness statements, preparing hearing bundle, briefing counsel
Final Hearing & Judgment
Full tribunal hearing with judgment and remedy determination
Example Pricing Scenarios
Simple unfair dismissal claim
Straightforward case, settles before final hearing
£2,400-£3,000 (inc VAT)
Complex unfair dismissal with discrimination
Multiple claims, full tribunal hearing required
£5,400-£7,200 (inc VAT)
Wrongful dismissal (breach of contract)
Contract claim with notice pay dispute
£2,100-£3,600 (inc VAT)
Get Expert Legal Advice
Contact our unfair dismissal specialists for a consultation.